Categorized | Developing Domains

Why Development Can REDUCE the Resale Value of a Domain

Posted on 22 August 2010 by Andrei

Lots of people think that developing their entire portfolio or at least a decent percentage of it is the way to go. After all, even if the domain doesn’t end up generating more revenue, development at least increases the resale value of a domain. Right? WRONG!

Revenue Multiples 101

Most of you probably don’t buy sites on a regular basis but those who do can confirm that there’s a HUGE discrepancy when it comes to revenue multiples. On the one hand, if you have a website which relies exclusively on search engine traffic and want to sell it at its market value, you shouldn’t expect more than 6x – 8x MONTHLY revenue. Yes, m-o-n-t-h-l-y!

Now, of course, a complex site with a consistent traffic/revenue track record as well as with plenty of room to grow and an actual business model (not just a traffic source or two, not just a monetization method or two etc.) can be sold for a lot more in terms of multiples but let’s face it, most websites developed by the average domainer do NOT belong in this category, as I’ve explained here and here 🙂

OK but What If I Only Sell the Domain Based on Its Inherent Value?

It should be clear that you shouldn’t expect more than 6x – 8x monthly rev based on the fundamentals of a mediocre website. But doesn’t having a premium domain help? Of course it can help but a lot of times, you are doing more harm than good by turning a good domain into a mediocre (at best) website.

If the domain is actually great, then a serious developer who has a respectable budget and wants to turn it into a website which actually provides value will think twice about buying it from you if it has been turned into a mediocre website.

Why? Because the average domainer who develops websites usually ends up screwing up royally by:

1) Building links too aggressively -> a Google penalty
2) Using too many ad units -> AdSense issues
3) Turning the domain into a thin site which didn’t pass a manual check -> a Google penalty

… and so on.

In other words, if I’m a serious developer and want to buy a domain from you, I’ll think twice about doing it if you turned it into something like a minisite for one simple reason: crappy development carries more risk than you imagine.

If the domain got banned by Google because the previous owner built links too aggressively (for example), I’ll have to work a lot harder and invest more money in order to fix everything.

If the AdSense account of the previous owner got closed because the domain was turned into a MFA (Made For AdSense) site, I might end up being in trouble.

The list could go on and on but since I don’t want to turn this post into a novel, I’ll stop here and make it clear one final time that:

Crappy development REDUCES the resale value of a domain!

61 Comments For This Post

  1. Xdreamer Says:

    Agree, tough job selling a banned site. Better to build only a few good sites with less risk if you want to sell them.

  2. Mike Says:

    Yes, but proper website development would definitely increase the income from domain per month and sale value of the domain/website and only a crazy person would sell a premium domain for multiple of income.

  3. jb Says:

    Putting a decent site on a valuable domain name ALWAYS increases its value during a sale.

    Sell it offline through a broker and you can easily get 5 to 10 times yearly rev.


    Building too many links aggressively is not a Google penalty. Building a lot of links over a couple of weeks and then stopping is what gets you flagged.

    Adsense sucks for monetization. There are at least 5 other services that beat it everytime.

    Building a thin site that doesn’t pass manual check…

    First of all very few sites even get a manual review. You have to have a site ranking in the top 10 of a very competitive market to even get a review. Google knows the value of every keyword on every organic listing. They know how much you’ll make in the #1 spot.

    Second, there is no such thing as a “thin” site to Google. I have 6 page sites that rank in the top 3 all over the place.

    I do agree with your last statement that CRAPPY sites hurt you. However, you probably should have added that to your title.

  4. Domain Sales Says:

    Other domainers understand penalties and such, end-users do not, they fall in love with the domain name or idea… not the development already done – good or bad they just want the name, they may find the domain name in the search engines if its listed.
    Penalties are usually short lived, 60 days or so, it takes a lot of abuse by a domain owner to have a domain permanently banned if ever.

  5. Andrei Says:

    @jb: AdSense sucks for monetization? Don’t take this the wrong way but this statement is so hilarious that I don’t even know where to start. I’d love to hear what the 5 other services that beat it every time are 🙂

    Oh and of course I’m talking about SCALABLE solutions because it all ultimately boils down to scalability, not an affiliate program for a product/service related to just one niche. Lots of people hate on Google but the thing is, most publishers would be screwed without AdSense. Love them or hate them, they are huge and that’s not going to change anytime soon.

    Finally, as far as your 6-page website is concerned, there’s no doubt in my mind that it’s ranking now. Anyone can provide lots of examples but here’s what they can’t do: provide verifiable examples of 6-page websites such as the one you’ve mentioned which have been ranking for decent terms over a period of 3-4 years or more. I’m sure I don’t have to explain why.

    @Domain Sales: this post is not about selling to end users, it’s about selling to serious developers at fair market prices. As explained here:

    “If the domain is actually great, then a serious developer who has a respectable budget and wants to turn it into a website which actually provides value will think twice about buying it from you if it has been turned into a mediocre website.”

  6. Leonard Britt Says:

    I’ll agree that many domainers including myself have to continue learning about the development, design & SEO process but I sold a domain in June for $3K which hosted a website I had developed (I relaunched on another domain a couple of weeks later). The buyer never inquired how much I was making on the site but that domain sale was for more than a thousand times my monthly earnings. The buyer was a developer who already had other sites in the same category and knew they could do a better job with it than I was doing but the site had somehow made it to page one of Google, Yahoo, Bing for its keywords and so from day one the buyer’s site was already receiving traffic. Since then, it has moved to the top spots of page one because they do a better job of providing fresh content.

  7. Andrei Says:

    @Leonard Britt: glad to hear that things worked out for both parties involved, I always love win-win situations. Maybe your website was decent, maybe he analyzed your backlink profile and didn’t find lots of questionable elements, there are lots of possibilities and referring to them would be pointless since I do not know anything about the website in question.

    Or, even if we’re talking about a low-quality minisite, there are definitely always exceptions but for the most part, developers will think twice before purchasing a domain if it is currently being used as a mediocre website.

  8. Steroids UK Says:

    as someone who has been too lazy to develop any of his domains i loved this post.

  9. Rob Monster - Epik Says:

    Seems like a provocative post to me.

    Yes, people die flying in planes. They usually don’t.

    Yes, you can destroy value be developing. You usually won’t.

    I think the biggest risk is legacy — if you sell Malware or Adult content, a future buyer may not be interested in that baggage or prior association.

    For example, we are developing for the owner and will auction it on 9/16 at Epik DevCon. used to be an adult site. We developed a product site which should go live shortly.

    Other than that, I can’t really think of an example where a domain is better off parked. Seriously, parking just trashes all indexing and pagerank value of the name and pays not much. Why bother.

  10. Andrei Says:

    @Rob: I am not referring to meaningful development when I’m saying that it reduces the resale value of a domain. I’m referring to crappy sites built by people who want to make a quick buck.

    Each and every year, the Web is flooded by beginners and a lot of them think that a “register 100 domains and turn them into minisites” business model makes sense. After buying and my other blog, I’ve been receiving quite a few emails from beginners who expect to succeed with such a way of thinking.

    Unfortunately, they’ll only end up learning a few painful lessons the hard way and that’s what my series of posts is all about: making it clear that having a business model which revolves around minisites just doesn’t make sense.

    There are far better ways to make money out there, crappy development does not increase the resale value of a good domain and the list could go on and on. I know that the current parking situation makes people jump on the mass development bandwagon but that’s just plain wrong IMO. Polluting the Web with crappy sites is just not worth it in the long run and as domainers, we’re better off turning a handful of excellent domains into sites which actually provide value and finding other ways to monetize the direct navigation traffic of our remaining portfolio.

  11. Rob Monster - Epik Says:

    @Andrei – Thanks for clarifying. On this we can agree. Amateur development can be damaging to your domain’s health. A lot of folks really underestimate the importance of (1) business model, (2) design, and (3) SEO. Nailing these 3 is half the battle.

  12. jb Says:


    The one thing (among many) that you’re ignoring about Google ranking is relevance. It is the core of their business model. The reason why 6 page or 10 page or 12 page sites can continue to rank for years and years (now and into the future) is because the content on them is the most relevant for a particular search query.

    Tapping into the long tail with a well done site that was only created as part of a domain flip/sale is far more valuable than parking since you:

    A – establish legitimate search traffic and increase value.

    B – age your domain with content that is thematically relevant to your domain’s suggested topic (athough admittedly, this is not always possible – as in the case of short brand oriented ones). This builds Trust Rank on your domain – which is HUGE in today’s SEO world. Again, increasing value.

    C – Develop PageRank which increases value.

    And btw – if you think Adsense is a the best bang for the buck, that, my friend is what’s hilarious. You clearly do not do much development and monetization outside of parking.

    Adsense revenue is now calculated on a domain and page basis. You can get traffic in credit cards and get $.30 a click with a crappy site.

    Again, crappy development hurts. Unless you have large, evergreen market single word names.

  13. Andrei Says:

    @jb: you haven’t answered my question. Forget about 5, name just two or three scalable alternatives which were able to outperform AdSense time and time again. Again, scalable, not just something that worked great for a site or two.

    Let’s assume that 1,000 site admins (various niches) want to try something different. What should they replace their AdSense code with? I’ve asked this question to lots of folks who bash AdSense (I know they’re not perfect but on the other hand, we can’t ignore their HUGE role either) numerous times and, needless to say, I’m still waiting for an answer 🙂

    And as far as small sites and your “(now and into the future)” statement are concerned, please take a moment and review Google’s attitude over the last couple of years. They do not like small sites and while you can indeed get them to rank, it’s a constant cat & mouse game and playing cat and mouse with your main traffic source is not exactly what I’d call a sustainable and especially scalable business model.

  14. Poor Uncle Says:

    You made some great points. I guess it is like owning a foreclosed abandon piece of property trespassed by druggies and homeless on a prime location.

  15. Stephen Douglas_Successclick Says:

    @ Andrei,

    You completely leave out the “brand” equation of a domain name. It doesn’t matter to any company who KNOWS they need a generic descriptive domain, or someone who likes an unusual brand, like “”.

    If anything, a LANDING PAGE turns off more buyers than a nice little minisite when a business decides it needs a domain name for it’s online marketing top positioning. You really think that any domainer is going to do “bad SEO” and get banned on Google — I sense a subtle referral to two year old complaints about Whypark here.

    @Rob Monster – If anything, Rob Monster is correct. If a domainer has a nice site (and most of them do if they decide to build out), a potential buyer who is interested in the domain will be encouraged to nab the domain because they don’t want this domain to compete with their current site and prodserv.

    Your logic here is based solely on negative values, without taking into consideration any “smarts” used by most domainers, and the fact that the domain itself sets the value, regardless of its “m-o-n-t-h-l-y” revenue. I paid thousands of dollars for DigitalMammogram/ before most people ever heard of the new breast cancer testing process, and it made nothing for years.

    I built it out with some custom pages on Whypark, probably spent about 90 minutes total on it… and since then I’ve turned down several high four figure offers for each of the domains (more than 300% profit than what I paid).

    You can’t ever compartmentalize a domain name… that what makes them so valuable. You based your blog article on one small faction of “website” mediocrity, and tried to apply it to domain value. It doesn’t work that way.

    But it got you some nice comments and traffic! I like smart thinkers in that sense… 😉
    *Let The Bodies Hit The Floor

  16. Andrei Says:

    @Stephen Douglas_Successclick: the title of this post is “Why Development Can REDUCE the Resale Value of a Domain” and not “Why Development Will REDUCE the Resale Value of a Domain”, please read my reply to Rob’s comment.

    I’d be the world’s biggest moron to say that development in general reduces the resale value of a domain, that’s definitely not the case. What I’m referring to is crappy development and not development in general.

    And as far as this question is concerned:

    “You really think that any domainer is going to do “bad SEO” and get banned on Google”

    My answer is a very clear “Yes” because let’s face it, most domainers are beginners when it comes to SEO. There’s nothing wrong with that, we all started somewhere but we do need to see things for what they are.

    You are mistaken if you think that only extreme approaches such as blatant spam will get you in trouble with search engines, especially the big G. Things have changed and this is only the beginning, let’s just say that managing the “love-hate” relationship everyone who optimizes sites has going on with search engines is already extremely hard if you’re interested in long-term sustainability and it will only get harder.

  17. David Says:

    Assuming the minisite content is targeted to the domain keywords I don’t believe a site will be a negative. With that said, a site will also likely not increase the domains value.

    A benefit to the minisite is your domain can slowly grow its traffic thanks to SEO work but a parked page will not.

    As far as revenue goes, a parked page will do much better but that assumes the domains get the same traffic numbers and the parked page gets typein traffic. If not, development is much better.

    As a side note, never had an end-use (non-domainer) buyer ever ask about the website, its revenue or traffic stats. Even if we offered to give that information the buyers did not want to look at it. Only domainers ask those kind of questions.

  18. Andrei Says:

    @David: when it comes to end users, you’re right, most of them won’t care but this article is not about how poor development can affect the resale value in the eyes of end users. It’s about how it can reduce the resale value in the eyes of professional developers who buy domains/websites at their fair market value 🙂

  19. Lang Varkey Says:

    Finally, I found the information I was looking for. I have been doing research on this subject, and for four days I keep entering sites that are supposed to have what I’m looking for, only to be disappointed with the lack of what I wanted. I wish I could have located your website sooner! I had about 25% of what I was looking for and your website has that, and the rest of what I needed to complete my research. Thank you and keep up the good work!

  20. Stephen Douglas_Successclick Says:


    Sorry, I didn’t know you were referring to “noobie” domain investors. I don’t call “beginners” the title “domainers” unless they bought their at least one domain for $1000+ !


  21. Attila Says:

    Just curious, is there a website or list where you can search to see if domain is blacklisted with google? Or is it one of those risks you take when buying a domain.

  22. self certification mortgages Says:

    It is really very exciting to Make Money Online from Google, Adbrite and Infolinks. All you need to do is make a website with great content and attract visitors.thanks..

  23. self defense weapons Says:

    A simple first tier example of the validity of my proposition would be the domain forums themselves. When people post domains for sale, without posting any prices, the overwhelming response is ‘nothing’. People don’t bother to approach the seller.

  24. fsbo Says:


    I just wanted to let you know that I have been watching for a a couple of months on and off and I would like to sign up for the daily feed. I am not to computer smart so I’ll give it a try but I will need some help. This is a good find and I would hate to lose contact, and maybe never find it again.

    Anyway, thanks again and I look forward to reading/posting again sometime!

  25. David Says:

    A major negative and significant issue with potential sales of developed websites (even a very small site i.e. 1 or 2 pages) is when a potential domain buyer goes to the URL and sees an active website he may assume since it is a site it’s likely not for sale.

    Therefore, the possible buyer (end-users in particular) may think why bother inquiring, and they quickly exit the page looking for a different domain, or maybe hand registering an alternative extension, or going with a slight name variation.

    For those working on developing all their names thinking development will help sales, this may come as a surprise.

  26. Stephen Douglas_Successclick Says:


    Whypark has a very distinct, top of the page “This Domain For Sale” link, so that’s doubtful. You do bring up an important point though. Maybe a developed site needs more than one link to announce the domain is for sale.

    Maybe, the “DOMAIN FOR SALE” link needs to be double-sized and bolded!! Oh no, now you got me paranoid! Thanks a lot, David.

  27. self defense weapons Says:

    Hi very nice title sharing telling is that Why Development Can REDUCE the Resale Value of a Domain…

  28. e-mail lookup Says:

    Great domain selling tips. I haven’t thought of this subject from this point. Although crappy development could decrease the value of a domain, but proper actions could make up the previous problems related to the domain…

  29. self defense weapons Says:

    I think are really good. All .doms, no hyphens, all highly searched keywords, all great branding, all good markets like travel, real estate, insurance, loans, cars…

  30. Carroll Laster Says:

  31. wykończenia wnętrz Krakow Says:

    My friend gave me address to this site, thanks!

  32. make money online best ways Says:

    Hi, You obviously are an individual who recognizes the energy of focus and how to generate ambitions that you just achieve step by step.Bravo to you.In my individual lifestyle I have only witnessed accomplishment when We’ve kept my concentrate and built the actions necessary to attain my plans – quite minor takes place by change alone. This is one thing I like to regularly share with my readers.Really, I’m delighted to examine about other peoples success by way of laser like focus and you’ve got it.Continued good results for you,David

  33. COP COPINE Says:

    Hi I love this forum I’m also passionated in extreme sport and techniques to be significantly powerful…I discovered a piece technology that make me much more efficient I also like mode and fashion. Thanks again for your discussion board Bye COP COPINE

  34. David Says:

    Stephen Douglas earlier said “Maybe, the “DOMAIN FOR SALE” link needs to be double-sized and bolded!! Oh no, now you got me paranoid! Thanks a lot, David.”

    However, there is still a problem Stephen because an obvious Domain For Sale announcement can make the visitor a bit uncomfortable seeing it and may also has negativity on potential PPC clicks too (and a much greater impact on any product sales a site may be hoping to get).

  35. Stephen Douglas_Successclick Says:

    Hi David,

    It’s not a secret that I’m not a big PPC fan. Non-Transparent “revenue providers” such as the top SE’s, are not my cup of tea. Plus, I know the secret of the PPC winners in this business, and they aren’t making money off great generic descriptive domains on PPC (cuz they will have built out significant websites utilizing direct sales, affiliates sales, or inhouse fulfillment prodservs).

    The people who make the most off PPC are typo investors and TMers. This isn’t my area. My area of expertise is flipping or selling to end users. This is, in fact, the safest and best way to make fast money if you’re paying attention.

    I don’t care if anyone clicks on adlinks on my sites. What I want is at LEAST ONE visitor to be a potential buyer as an end user worried about what a competitor might be putting up with that domain name if that visitor doesn’t purchase it.

    In other words: My 12 years of domain monetizing experience has shown that the amount of time you spend parking your domains hoping for PPC payouts can be obliterated by the sale of ONE domain to an enduser.

    Few domainers make more than $3000 a month in PPC revenue. However, a LOT of domainers make over $10k a month FLIPPING their domains. Which is more important to any domain investor? Trickling monthly revenue, or a smash hit that pays for renewing 200 domains they own and can continue trying to flip?

    It’s about the math and the types of domains you buy. I GUARANTEE YOU that no typo or TM domain investor will NOT sell you their domains for a price you can’t recover in 10 years. Why should they?

    Hope this clears up why I like Whypark and building up sites that end users will be anxious about… and motivated to make offers to buy.

  36. Charlie Gazza Says:

    Valuable details and exceptional style you got here! I would like to ideal wishes for sharing your thoughts and time into the stuff you write-up!

  37. ksiegowosc wroclaw Says:

    Fajne – mogę część na swojej stronie wykorzystać?

  38. Andromoda Says:

    Nice text but I think that your language can’t be understood by noobs… Maybe make notes more understandable?

  39. Langkawi Says:

    I made the mistake of building too many links to quick with one of my sites and it did get banned by google , i left it alone and all was ok after 6 months.

  40. Afrika Says:

    A whole tips to consider before buying a site-it is also risky business to venture into cautiously

  41. Adam Says:

    I agree but this is not always the case… another question: what would everyone do if you had 3 billion dollars?

  42. iran agenda Says:

    excellent for the iran agenda

  43. 8x8 gazebo Says:

    After I originally commented I clicked the -Notify me when new feedback are added- checkbox and now every time a comment is added I get 4 emails with the identical comment. Is there any manner you possibly can take away me from that service? Thanks!

  44. Kent Kapoor Says:

    I completely agree with everything you have mentioned. Actually, I browsed through your several other content articles and I’m sure you are definitely correct. Great job with this particular blog.

  45. vit b12 Says:

    vit b12 vitamin news

  46. Arcadia Says:

    Plan as far ahead as you can. Most airlines set aside only a few seats on many desirable flights at the lower rates. The real best bargains often sell out very quickly. On the other hand, if a particular flight is not selling as well as expected, air carriers sometimes make more discount seats available for a particular flight just before the advance-purchase deadline expires. For example, if the lowest fare has a 21-day advance-purchase requirement but is sold out for most dates, and you can go any time, ask about fare availability on flights 21 or 22 days from when you call.

  47. Azucena Says:

    Comprised of seventeen thousand islands, Indonesia is a sure smorgasbord surprise. Wide-eyed guests could simply marvel at the wondrous beauty before their eyes but have to settle for a few courses in order to enjoy each trip to the largest archipelago of the world.

  48. Amnisty Says:

    Register so the State Department can better assist you in an emergency: Register your travel plans with the State Department through a free online service. This will help them contact you if there is a family emergency in the U.S., or if there is a crisis where you are traveling. In accordance with the Privacy Act, information on your welfare and whereabouts will not be released to others without your express authorization.

  49. Adia Says:

    If you are looking for a romantic getaway, look no further than Seattle Washington for your next vacation. There are so many wonderfully romantic things to do in this wonderful city and it rains literally half the time, which provides an excellent excuse for cuddling beneath an umbrella. Even those who are romantically challenged would be hard pressed not to find something romantic to do in this great city.

  50. Athan Says:

    The central areas around the Palace Museum (Forbidden City) and city gates as well as the lakes – ZhongNanHai, BeiHai and HouHai – have been designated as protected landmark districts that retain the features of Old Beijing. The Forbidden City at the centre is surrounded in concentric circles by the Inner City and Outer City.

  51. Apartments for sale in Egypt Says:

    […]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine a few unrelated data, nonetheless genuinely worth taking a look, whoa did one study about Mid East has got much more problerms at the same time […]

  52. homeowners insurance palm desert Says:

    […]one of our guests just lately recommended the following website[…]

  53. LinkMarket Says:

    My brother suggested I may like this blog. He used to be entirely right. This post truly made my day. You cann’t imagine just how so much time I had spent for this info! Thank you!

  54. Submit Article Says:

    Stunning story there. What happened after? Take care!

  55. USA Fone Says:

    You really make it appear really easy with your presentation but I find this matter to be really something which I believe I’d by no means understand. It sort of feels too complex and very large for me. I’m looking ahead on your next post, I’ll try to get the dangle of it!

  56. Cheap Site Link Says:

    naturally like your web-site but you have to check the spelling on several of your posts. Many of them are rife with spelling problems and I find it very bothersome to inform the reality on the other hand I will definitely come again again.

  57. Software guide and review Says:

    Valuable info. Fortunate me I found your web site unintentionally, and I am shocked why this accident didn’t came about earlier! I bookmarked it.

  58. Next Shoe Says:

    Somebody necessarily help to make severely posts I’d state. This is the very first time I frequented your web page and thus far? I surprised with the analysis you made to make this actual publish incredible. Great process!

  59. Jere Wallentine Says:

    composed by sbsbsb0416 Heya i’m for the first time here. I found this board and I find It really useful & it helped me out a lot. I hope to give something back and aid others like you aided me.

  60. Tam Vongsamphanh Says:

    composed by sbsbsb0416 I like your blog. It sounds pretty nice. I would share this with my friends.

  61. Grover Luarca Says:

    composed by sbsbsb0416 When I originally commented I clicked the ?°Notify me when new comments are added?± checkbox and now each time a comment is added I get three emails with the same comment. Is there any way you can remove people from that service? See ya!

2 Trackbacks For This Post

  1. Allures Which Make Cheap Flights To Las Vegas Hot Says:

    Cool sites…

    we came across a cool site that you might enjoy. Take a look if you want…

  2. sim only pay as you go Says:

    Read was interesting, stay in touch……

    […]please visit the sites we follow, including this one, as it represents our picks from the web[…]……